This painting derives from one of Ter Borch's earliest compositions. A related drawing was executed by the precocious artist when he was only eight years old.
Possibly Jan Palthe (b. 1717 - d. 1769), Leyden; March 20, 1770, posthumous Palthe sale, Leyden, lot 219 or 220. By 1936/1937, Martha Dana (Mrs. William Robert) Mercer (b. 1872 - d. 1960), Doylestown, PA [see note 1]; 1960, probably sold through Samuel T. Freeman and Co., Philadelphia [see note 2]. 1960, New York art market [see note 3]. 1960, Pieter de Boer, Amsterdam and Lucerne; 1961, sold by De Boer to the MFA. (Accession Date: September 20, 1961) NOTES:  Mrs. Mercer's heir and niece, Walpurga Baroness von Friesen, wrote to Angelica Rudenstine of the MFA (April 28, 1962) that she was certain her aunt had purchased the painting, though she did not know where. She recalled seeing it in the Mercers' home in Doylestown, noting that the last time she had visited was in 1936/1937.  Helen H. Gemmill of the Bucks County Historical Society wrote to Scott Schaefer of the MFA (August 1, 1978) that "Freeman Auctioneers of Philadelphia listed 'Man on Horse' in their special sale of Mrs. Mercer's better things". Freeman did hold an auction of Mrs. Mercer's belongings (rare and valuable books) on September 23, 1960, and it may have passed onto the New York art market at that time.  S. J. Gudlaugsson of the RKD wrote to Angelica Rudenstine (May 1, 1962) that a New York dealer had sent him a photograph of the picture in autumn, 1960, and that it later passed to De Boer.
Juliana Cheney Edwards Collection